No mayonnaise definitely does NOT mean boring with the RecipeTin No Mayo Coleslaw! We love this Slaw because it’s interesting enough to compensate for no mayo in the dressing, refreshing enough to pair with rich mains, but still has the signature Coleslaw “juiciness”.
No Mayo Coleslaw
This is the RecipeTin Family recipe for a Coleslaw made without mayonnaise that we truly believe stacks up to traditional Coleslaw in all it’s mayo-laden glory.
Don’t get me wrong. I love a good creamy Coleslaw.
But typically, Coleslaw gets suggested when we’re planning rich Southern menus for a family dinner. Think – meat, sweet BBQ sauce, and sometimes, full throttle deep frying.
And typically, someone sensible suggests that mayo Coleslaw might be too rich with all that meat, shouldn’t we opt for a lighter salad?
And typically (in pre-No-Mayo-Coleslaw-invention days) someone else would huff and puff about how Coleslaw is a classic side for a Southern blow out, and how we’re clearly not counting calories for this meal so why skimp on Slaw?
And so on, back and forth, until the family WhatsApp thread to decide the menu for a “simple” family dinner is many, many swipes long.
There is still much back and forth on family dinner menus. But since the creation of this No Mayo Slaw, there is no back and forth about slaw!
The combination of ingredients in this No Mayo Slaw might be surprising – but it’s addictive! The fennel and caraway seeds are quite subtle, and dill brings a wonderful freshness.
What you need for Coleslaw without Mayonnaise
Here’s what goes in our No Mayo Coleslaw:
- Cabbage – any green cabbage works fine here (but not Chinese cabbage which is more delicate so it will get too soggy);
- Fennel – shaved thinly so the flavour is quite mild, brings a fabulous freshness to this Slaw;
- Dill – this herb is the perfect match in this salad! Use more than you think you need;
- Apple – shaved finely, it adds a subtle sweet juiciness. Once dressed, it stops it from going brown (the pictured salad is a day old);
- Caraway seeds – reinforces the aniseed flavour of the fennel, but it’s subtle, we don’t use much. This is a secret ingredient that makes people pause when they take their first bite, wondering why it’s so good!
- Dressing ingredients – nothing ground breaking here. The only thing I’ll mention is that we use less salt (1/2 tsp) and more sugar (2 tsp) than you might expect. It’s because we like to give this more sweetness than saltiness, akin to traditional creamy Coleslaw.
How to make No Mayo Coleslaw
Lots of shredding and mandolin action for the vegetables. Then just toss it all together and leave it to wilt for a good hour or two. (Because nobody likes coleslaw with stiff cabbage sprigs sticking out all over the place. We want it floppy and juicy!).
What we serve with No Mayo Slaw
As I mentioned in the opening, we (well, my brother!) created this No Mayo Slaw as a more refreshing alternative to traditional mayonnaise Coleslaw to pair with rich mains. In particular, Southern foods where Coleslaw is a traditional side option:
One of my personal favourite “special treat” dinners is a Fried Chicken Southern Feast. Here is a menu for dishes that we made for a recent family dinner:
Southern Fried Chicken Dinner
Also, a couple more serving ideas:
- Meal salad – toss through tuna or shredded chicken
- In sandwiches – ham, tuna, chicken, avocado
Keeps for days and days!
One of the best things going for this salad is that it keeps for 3 to 4 days, much like creamy Coleslaw. In fact, I think it’s better made the day before, after all the flavours have had a chance to meld together.
So make a big tub of it, and bring it out day after day!! – Nagi x
PS Forgot to mention – if you love creamy slaw but want to skip the heavy mayo version, try a Yogurt Slaw Dressing. It’s very, very good!
Watch how to make it
Our best No Mayo Coleslaw
The flavour of the fennel and caraway seeds it quite subtle – in fact, many people don’t even realise it’s in there, they just know it’s delicious!
- 1/4 large head green cabbage (or 1/2 small head) , shredded (~12 cups, Note 1)
- 1 medium fennel bulb , trimmed, halved and shaved at 1.5 mm on a mandolin (Note 2)
- 1 red apple (any kind is fine), halved and thinly sliced (1.5 mm thick)
- 1 cup dill leaves, roughly chopped (about 1 whole bunch)
- 2 tsp caraway seeds (Note 4)
- 2 small clove garlic , minced
- 3 tbsp apple cider vinegar
- 5 tbsp olive oil
- 2 tsp Dijon mustard
- 1 1/2 tsp caster sugar (Note 5)
- 1/2 tsp salt (Note 5)
- 1/8 tsp black pepper
Dressing: Shake Dressing ingredients in a jar.
Toss! Place cabbage, fennel, apple and dill in a very large bowl. Pour over Dressing, toss well.
Sprinkle with caraway seeds then toss again.
Set aside for at least 1 hour to allow cabbage to wilt. Give it a good toss, then transfer to serving bowl and serve!
Storage: Keeps perfecty for 3 to 4 days in the fridge. Dressing stops apple from going brown. Best to bring to room temperature before serving.
2. Fennel – the body of a medium one is about the size of a baseball (small is tennis ball size).
3. 1.5 mm = 0.06 inches thick. Not sure how millimetres are expressed in the US!
4. Caraway seeds have a similar aniseed flavour to the fennel and dill. Don’t want to use too much, just a touch to add an extra something-something to this Slaw!
5. Salt & sugar – this dressing specifically has less salt and more sugar than you’d expect because we like it to have a Coleslaw-like flavour which errs more towards a bit sweet than salty.
6. Nutrition per serving.
Life of Dozer
A Physio taught me to use tennis balls to loosen tight muscles in my back (ie lying on them on a rug). It will come as no surprise to anyone that the balls keep going missing, and I keep finding them in Dozer’s not-very-clever hiding places – such as buried under cushions and blankets on his bed.
Dozer – that innocent look on your face ain’t fooling anyone!